The Magazine Issue

The editors of Outreach Magazine, particularly Lynne Marian and Lindy Lowry, have done their usual good work.

Be sure to get the print issue if you do not already have it. The profiles of the churches are excellent.

Some thoughts on the issue

Early on in the magazine planning, I suggested a "confessions of a megachurch pastor" article. The plan was to talk to some of these megachurch pastors and hear their challenges, struggles, and victories. It is worth a read.

Ron Forseth did the interviews that were compiled and edited by Jeannie Choi. Ron is a great brother with a heart for the church. I have had the privilege of spending time with Ron and his family (even bunked over on the spare bed one night). I love reading everything Ron writes. (Ron also runs SermonCentral.com and I will be posting soon on what they have been doing.)

Also, the Outreach folks were very gracious with me as we worked on the lists. First, I wanted to change the formula on how to list "fastest growing church." They agreed-- and I think it worked well. Second, we agreed to only include churches that wanted to participate, not creating estimates or using past data. They also asked me to write a trends piece.

Finally, I wanted to hold up a "missional" vision in one of my pieces, and you will see an article I wrote on the subject-- and several interviews here on the blog in the next few days.

Although I don't see the actual lists online, you can read a news release about the study here.

First Steps

How did we get the numbers? Our team started with previous Outreach 100 lists and contacted all the churches over the last several years. We also contacted all the major (and most minor) denominations in the U.S. to ask them to share their data... many graciously did.

We partnered with Leadership Network and Hartford Institute for Religion Research to share data from churches already on megachurch lists.

More Background on Leadership Network and Hartford

Since I mentioned Leadership Network and Hartford, let me share some of their recent projects.

If you are interested in the megachurch, you really should read Beyond Megachurch Myths, by Scott Thumma (from the Hartford Institute) and Dave Travis (from Leadership Network).

Then, if you are really brave, see Warren Bird's Ph.D. Dissertation, Megachurches as spectator religion: Using social network theory and free-rider theory to understand the spiritual vitality of America's largest-attendance churches. Warren is also with Leadership Network.

You can read about "free rider theory" here and read the dissertation to see how Warren applies it to the megachurch question.

Methodology

We made phone calls to all the churches on those lists. We asked each church for their average weekend worship attendance (adults and children). Churches that are doing multi-venue or multi-site services were asked to include numbers for all sites that were under the main church’s leadership and administrative structure.

Churches were contacted multiple times to obtain attendance numbers. Our team made phone calls but also sent faxes and emails to make sure that the request got to as many people as possible at a particular church. Once we received the numbers, we followed up again by email and/or fax to confirm those numbers to make sure that we were reporting accurately the statistics a church had given us. Accuracy was important to us, but (of course), they are only as accurate as the church's report.

Some, including churchrelevance.com, have already noticed that not all megachurches are listed. Some churches declined to participate, and we recognized that this was due to a variety of reasons… some just don’t see the need or value of “100 lists.” Others simply don’t want their numbers published for a variety of reasons. Other churches never responded to the multiple attempts our team made to gather the numbers.

In discussions with Outreach Magazine’s staff, we decided not to publish church numbers unless we heard from the churches themselves. This way, we avoided any question of whether or not we were “grandfathering” in churches based on reputation alone. Simply put: no report, no list. We think it makes for a better list.

Feedback

We created the blog for feedback, so let me invite you to share your thoughts.

If you have churches that “should” be on the list, feel free to post them here or email us at research@lifeway.com. We would love to improve the list and will publish updates here at the blog after confirming with the churches involved.

Also, feel free to post questions about the research here in this thread.

Conclusion

Please remember, lists are not for comparison. They are for learning and, hopefully, encouragement.

Our desire is that you might learn from these churches, see how God is at work, rejoice with them, and then find God's unique vision for your church: whether it meets in a coffee shop or a cathedral.