Topics
Series
Leadership Interview
Most Popular Posts
Alltop - Best of the Best
 

Liberals, Conservatives, People

Tuesday March 31, 2009   ~   5 Comments

A recent survey conducted by the Barna Group demonstrated some important differences between "liberals" and "conservatives" concerning faith, religion and spirituality.

lib_con.jpg

People's interest in - and reactions to - the social and political actions being made by President Obama and the Democratic-controlled Congress have heightened awareness of the different perspectives held by liberals and conservatives. A new study conducted by The Barna Group indicates that those differences are related to substantially different spiritual beliefs, behaviors and alignments.


Overall, the research shows that nearly one-third of all adults (32%) consider themselves to be "mostly conservative" on social and political matters, and about half as many (17%) claimed to be "mostly liberal" on such matters. The other half of the adult population generally takes a position somewhere in between those opposing viewpoints.

While most liberals and conservatives consider themselves Christian, a greater percentage is found among conservatives (94%vs 74%). And once we get beyond the simple title of "Christian," more differences emerge. For example, liberals are much less likely than conservatives to embrace Theism - that "God is the all-knowing, all-powerful creator of the world who still rules the universe today" (55% of liberals vs. 82% of conservatives). Liberals are also twice as likely as conservatives to be categorized as "unchurched" (40% vs. 19%). Half as many liberals believe the Bible is accurate in all it teaches (27% versus 63%, respectively); that Satan is real (17% versus 36%); and that they have a personal responsibility to evangelize (23% versus 48%).

Liberals are also far less likely than conservatives to strongly believe each of the following:

  • their religious faith is very important in their life (54% of liberals vs. 82% of conservatives);
  • a person cannot earn their way into Heaven by doing good deeds or being a good person (23% vs. 37%);
  • their faith is becoming an increasingly important moral guide in their life (38% vs. 70%);
  • the church they currently attend is very important in helping them find direction and fulfillment in life (37% vs. 62%);
  • their primary purpose in life is to love God with all their heart, mind, strength and soul (43% vs. 76%);
  • Jesus Christ did not commit sins during His time on earth (33% vs. 55%).

The survey also revealed that:

  • 2% of conservatives and 11% of liberals were atheist or agnostic
  • 15% of conservatives and 2% of liberals were Christian evangelicals
  • conservatives were twice as likely as liberals to be categorized as born again, based on their theological views about salvation (63% vs. 32%)
  • 21% of conservatives were associated with the Catholic church, compared to 30% among the liberals.


Why does this matter? Let me say that Barna's research consistently demonstrates that just because people identify themselves as "Christian" doesn't mean that they are following Christ or even hold to historic Christian beliefs. And claiming to be born-again does not mean that one has been transformed by God's grace. We're talking about subjective, individual perspectives of one's self. It's also important to understand that people are more than their political ideologies. Yet, knowing where people are coming from (what their beliefs, presuppositions, preferences and sympathies are) helps us to better preach the gospel, reason from the Scripture, and give an answer for the hope that we have within us. If you don't know who you're talking to you will have a more difficult time connecting with them, and connecting them to the gospel. Is your neighbor conservative or liberal? Churched or unchurched? Theistic, deistic, or atheistic? Ultimately we are not talking about labels, but people. This is why both research and relationships matter. The former helps us to see the big picture in our culture concerning the people we are trying to reach, and the latter is where we step into the work that God has called us to - reaching those very people.

Be sure to check out the whole article on Barna's survey, and then come back to discuss.

Posted on March 31, 2009 at 8:16 AM   ~   5 Comments

Tagged with: barna, conservative, liberal, politics, religious, research, survey

5 Comments

Excellent correlation between research and relationships. Job well done.

Barna's previous research also found that not all born-again adults in the U.S. may be considered "evangelical" Christians (something like 90 million non-evangelical born-again adults but only 15 million evangelical ones in the U.S.--which probably accounts for some of the great difficulties arising within local churches, and is a very good reason that evangelical Christians must reach across denominational lines in order to do world evangelization [been demonstrated that we cannot yet count on most of our own fellow church members in order to get it done; most SBCers are not evangelical born-again Christians]). The same research spoke to the categories of "notional" Christians (true believers only in their own minds or by their own--but not biblical--definitions), percentages/numbers of adherents to other faith claims, and atheists/agostics.

Good info, for knowing who we're talking to, I think.


David Troublefield
Minister of Missions/Education
Lamar Baptist Church
Wichita Falls, TX
david@lbcwf.org

I tend to be leery of people with a blatant agenda who conduct surveys even when I agree with the agenda. Makes me suspect their numbers and their methodology.

I get the impression from these numbers that Barna is trying to support the idea that a conservative political and social agenda is more Biblical and Christian than a liberal political and social agenda. In effect, he is trying to demonstrate that God is on his side politically. If this is the direction he is heading, then I have problems with that.

Jesus, when given the opportunity to take a conservative or liberal stand on the social or political issues of his day refused to sucked in. He chose disciples that were both Roman collaborators (Levi) and zealots (Simon). And when he did declare his political affiliation as a king to Pilate, he said his kingdom wasn't of this world.

I don't think our should be either.

It seems the term "evangelical"
somehow gets misused. If we say we are Christians, then we are Christ's followers. We have claimed Him as Lord and should agree to follow (or at least try) to follow His example and teachings. If this is true, it seems to me all Christians should fall under the classification of "evangelicals" according to the description given in the survey report. Jesus gave His followes the "great commission". It seems that's evangelical as it gets.

Although there are differences in conservative and liberal views in this article, it seems the survey conveys the definition of Christianity is as diverse among people as the people themselves. Does, "I believe in Christ", qulaify us as Christians?

The "evangelical" thing: it seems the difference is between "should" and "actually do."

I don't have the money to re-do Barna's research in order to prove that his firm got it wrong, and I don't recall hearing any other reasons for not trusting his survey results. That being the case, when self-identified Christians had the opportunity--anonymously--to say that they are or aren't as serious about their relationships with the Lord Jesus Christ as He is about them, most Christians chose to indicate that they aren't. If those folks actually are Christians, then it definitely appears that the matter is one discipleship (increasingly becoming more like Christ in values and attitudes and actions); "evangelical Christians," as Barna's research defines them/us, is exactly the kind of Christian my congregation is seeking to produce. We all have a 'ways to go!


David Troublefield
Minister of Missions/Education
Lamar Baptist Church
Wichita Falls, TX
david@lbcwf.org

Leave a comment

» Subscribe to these comments.
 
Recent Comments
Twitter Feed
    My Books
    Compelled by Love Comeback Churches   Breaking the missional Code
    Planting Missional Churches 11 Innocations in the Local Church   Spiritual Warfare and Missions
    Mission Shift Lost and Found   Perimeters of Light
    Small Group Resources

    Install Flash

    Get Adobe Flash player

    Schools Where I Teach
    Compelled by Love
    Ministry Partnerships
    Christianity Today Outreach magazine
    Catalyst Monthly Facts and Trends
    Christian Post
    imb connecting Baptist Center
    LifeWay: Research - Biblical Solutions for Life
    LifeWay: Biblical Solutions for Life
    Noteworthy Items
    Noteworthy Items